Food and overeating: why do we eat?
Food doesn’t always call to us because we’re hungry. Sometimes the cause is a long gap between meals, sometimes it’s tiredness, loneliness or the old habit of cleaning your plate. Here’s a simple way to tell when your body needs food and when you’re actually looking for something else.
Food, hunger and overeating
You know the feeling: your stomach isn’t really empty, but your hand still reaches for a cookie, a piece of candy or a sandwich. That doesn’t automatically mean your willpower is weak. Evelyn Tribole, MS, RD, co-author of the book Intuitive Eating, explained to M&F Hers that overeating has both biological and emotional causes.
The biological cause is often very simple: you’ve gone too long without eating. When five hours have passed since your last meal, the next craving can hit as a big, fast wave. It feels like you’re losing control, even though your body is simply doing what it’s built to do: asking for energy.
Another common trap is eating too little during the day. Say you do a pretty tough workout in the morning, but afterwards you don’t have much appetite. At lunch you take a smaller portion. By evening your body’s energy debt is so big that eating calmly becomes difficult. So overeating can come not from laziness, but from holding back for too long.
Why is food especially tempting in the evening?
For many people, the evening is the hardest time of day. The day is over, work or school no longer presses on you, the phone is in your hand and the quiet sets in. When there’s nothing on TV, nothing interesting online and your head feels empty, eating can become a way to kill time.
Honestly, emotional eating doesn’t always mean major stress or anger. Sometimes it’s simply discomfort. Boredom. Loneliness. Restlessness. Some people don’t recognize these feelings right away and only notice that they’d like to snack on something.
For people on a diet, the picture can get even murkier. If chocolate is completely off limits, a single piece can feel like a failure. Then you don’t stop at two or three pieces; you eat more, because the thought in your head is: everything is ruined now anyway. In reality, nothing is ruined. One choice doesn’t have to turn into a whole evening.
Three questions before the next bite
Tribole recommended asking yourself three questions in the moment of overeating. They aren’t meant to make you feel guilty. Rather, they help you slow down before your hand automatically moves on to the next bite.
- Am I actually hungry? Did I eat enough today? If there’s no biological hunger, move on to the next question.
- What am I feeling right now? If it isn’t hunger, it may be an emotional state: discomfort, tension, loneliness or simply tiredness.
- What do I need to deal with this feeling? The key words are Now and Need. If you need rest, quiet or someone to talk to, food won’t really solve it.
This doesn’t mean the answer has to come right away. Sometimes a person simply doesn’t know what they need. But the asking itself already opens a door: maybe what you need isn’t one more sandwich, but ten minutes of peace, a shower, a walk or just going to bed.
Food, protein and feeling full
If your goal is to cut back on overeating, what your meal is made of helps too. M&F Hers asked whether protein is the most filling nutrient. Tribole answered that, realistically, yes: protein generally fills you up best, followed by carbohydrates and fats.
There’s one important nuance here. Protein works better when you eat it in solid form. Solid food fills the stomach and takes longer to digest. If the same thing is in liquid form, some of that benefit may be lost. That’s why a drink may not give you the same satisfaction as a real meal.
The volume of food matters too. Your stomach responds not only to calories, but also to how much there is on the plate and in the stomach. If you eat food that is low in calories but large in volume, you can still end up feeling full. Looking at an empty plate, your stomach may feel psychologically empty, even if on paper everything seemed fine.
When does overeating become a problem?
We all eat too much from time to time. A birthday, a long day, great food, bad timing. Occasional overeating is normal, and the body often regulates itself. One bigger dinner doesn’t make you a broken person.
It’s a different story when it repeats every evening or every weekend. Then it’s worth looking at the pattern, not just the food. What usually happens beforehand? Do you eat too little during the day? Does the evening bring loneliness? Is some feeling so uncomfortable that you’d like to push it down quickly?
A simple truth: listening to your body doesn’t mean blindly following every craving. It means learning to tell hunger, habit and feeling apart. When your stomach signals that it’s had enough, you can stop eating. When your head says you’d like more, it’s worth pausing to ask: what do I actually need right now?
FAQ
Does eating in the evening always mean overeating?
No. If you’re genuinely hungry and you ate too little during the day, an evening meal can be completely normal. It becomes a problem when you regularly eat more than your body needs and feel bad afterwards.
Should you avoid chocolate completely?
Usually not. A total ban can actually make cravings stronger. For many people, calm permission works better: you take two or three pieces, eat them mindfully and move on.
Does listening to your body help you stop overeating?
Yes, but it’s a skill, not a trick. Start by noticing hunger and fullness. If you notice a repeating pattern that feels out of control, it’s worth seeking help from a nutrition counselor or a healthcare professional.
Author: M&F Hers, translated by Renita Hunt
Source: WHO – healthy eating.
Come and train! ArtGym
